Understanding Document Disclosure in Lawsuits
When you start or defend a lawsuit in Canada, you are required to disclose documents that are “relevant to any matter in issue in the action,” as set out in Rule 30.02 of Ontario’s Rules of Civil Procedure. This obligation applies to documents in your possession, control, or power, unless they are protected by legal privilege. Disputes about the scope of disclosure are common, as each side seeks information that may support its position. Courts have also long recognized that videos and digital recordings fall within the definition of a “document.”
Privacy Concerns in Personal Injury Lawsuits
In personal injury claims, including those arising from motor vehicle accidents or slip-and-fall incidents, defendants often arrange surveillance of the injured person. This practice is well established in litigation. Anyone bringing a personal injury lawsuit should be aware that aspects of their day-to-day activities may be observed and documented as part of the defence process.
The Expanding Role of Social Media and Digital Evidence
In 2025, the range of potential evidence is broader than ever. Beyond paper records, parties may seek information from social media platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, X (formerly Twitter), and BlueSky. Photos, text messages, smartphone data, and electronic journals can also become relevant. As digital footprints continue to grow, courts are increasingly asked to decide where to draw the line between disclosure obligations and personal privacy.
Legal Guidance on Privacy: Ibrahimova v. Cavanagh
This issue was recently considered by Justice Shaw in Ibrahimova et al. v. Cavanagh et al., 2025 ONSC 1152. The plaintiff experienced serious medical complications following a septic pregnancy loss, including the amputation of her left leg below the knee, a brain hemorrhage, seizures, and a kidney transplant. The defendant physicians sought access to video and audio recordings from the plaintiff’s in-home camera system.
The cameras were installed primarily for the plaintiff’s safety and to allow her husband to monitor her remotely while she was at home. They were not created for litigation purposes.
Balancing Evidence Disclosure and Privacy Rights
The defendants argued that the recordings were relevant to assessing the plaintiff’s claim for attendant care. Justice Shaw accepted that relevance alone does not end the analysis. Importantly, the court confirmed that starting a lawsuit does not mean a person gives up all privacy rights. Even where evidence may relate to issues in dispute, privacy interests must still be carefully weighed.
The Home as a Protected Private Space
Justice Shaw emphasized that a person’s home is where the most personal and private aspects of life take place. As a result, individuals have a heightened expectation of privacy in their own homes. In this case, the recordings were intended to support the plaintiff’s health and safety, not to document her daily life for legal scrutiny.
The Court’s Decision on In-Home Recordings
Ultimately, the court concluded that compelling disclosure of the in-home recordings would infringe the plaintiff’s significant privacy interests. Justice Shaw described such disclosure as “shockingly intrusive” and reaffirmed that the sanctity of the home must be respected, even within the litigation process.
What This Means for Private Videos and Digital Privacy
The decision reinforces the principle that private videos recorded inside the home, when not shared publicly, remain protected from disclosure in many circumstances. The court noted that the analysis could be different if such recordings had been posted on social media or otherwise made public.
Questions About Privacy in a Lawsuit?
Navigating document disclosure and privacy concerns can be difficult, particularly as technology becomes more integrated into daily life. If you have concerns about how personal or digital information may be treated in a lawsuit, speaking with a lawyer can help you better understand your rights and obligations.
Contact our office to arrange a free consultation.